November 19, 2026, 4:01 pm | Read time: 7 minutes
PETBOOK author Nina Ponath has described why she no longer puts up with everything in dog training classes. Her conclusion: If the relationship between human, dog, and trainer doesn’t fit, you can set boundaries and leave. As a dog trainer, I agree with her. At the same time, I want to add: Finding the right dog trainer is not a one-way street. In the end, both sides must be compatible.
Yes, You Can Leave. And Without Guilt
Let’s start with the obvious, which unfortunately is still not obvious. If you feel small, lectured, or embarrassed in a dog training class, you can leave. If you’re not allowed to ask questions, you can leave. If you witness dogs being yelled at or physically corrected, you should not only leave but also inform the relevant veterinary office. Ms. Ponath sums it up: You owe no one your time, money, or insecurity.
The fact that this needs to be said is sad enough. The term dog trainer is not protected in Germany, and alongside dedicated professionals, there is a lot of overconfidence. Insecure owners, especially with their first dog, often encounter people with a lot of conviction and little doubt. Those who have been treated condescendingly once have usually learned less than they have unlearned: namely, to trust themselves.
Personal Preference or Animal Welfare? There’s a Difference
In one aspect, I want to differentiate. The report states that the methods of dog training schools differ, and that’s okay. This is partly true. Whether someone uses a clicker, a whistle, a blanket as a place signal, or values a release command is a matter of personal preference and philosophy. These are debatable, and you can decide what fits into your daily life.
However, leash jerking, intimidation, choke collars, or submission are not matters of personal preference. Here, the variety of methods ends, and animal welfare begins. Prong collars and electric shock devices are banned in Germany, and for good reason. So if someone tells you that’s just their way of working, the only correct response is: Then please work without me and my dog.
The Other Side of the Street: Trainers Also Choose
Now comes the part that might be uncomfortable for some. We trainers also need to fit with our clients. This has nothing to do with arrogance but with professionalism. I can’t work with every dog, every problem, and every person. Anyone who doesn’t honestly say they’re not trained for aggression, severe anxiety, or biting incidents is acting negligently. A good trainer recognizes their limits and refers clients to colleagues, behavior consultants, or veterinarians.
Similarly, a trainer can say no if the chemistry isn’t right, if methods and expectations are too far apart, or if someone wants a miracle in an hour. This is not failure. A collaboration that doesn’t fit from the start costs both sides nerves and, in the worst case, the dog trust.
Also interesting: Expert on dog training on Instagram: “I am sometimes completely stunned”
What a Trainer Can Expect from You
Respect, as Nina Ponath demands, applies in both directions. A trainer can expect you to be honest, even if it’s uncomfortable. That you say if your dog has bitten before. That you admit if you haven’t done the homework instead of claiming it doesn’t work. That you keep appointments and ask follow-up questions instead of disappearing without a word.
And they can expect you to distinguish between uncomfortable and unworthy. If I tell you that your dog needs more exercise or that your body language contributes to the problem, it can be uncomfortable. But it’s not belittling; it’s information. Training where you never have to change anything isn’t training.
The Introduction Is an Equal Meeting
A reputable trainer offers a preliminary talk or a private session before the first course, not just so you can assess them. They also want to get to know you and your dog: How does the dog react to new stimuli? How do you interact? What are your goals, and are they realistic? This conversation often decides whether a collaboration works, and it’s entirely legitimate for both sides to say afterward: This fits, or: This doesn’t fit.
Use this opportunity honestly. If you only nod in the initial meeting and are later dissatisfied, you’ve done neither yourself nor the trainer any favors. Clearly state what you expect, what you don’t want, and how much time you can realistically invest. Being open from the start saves disappointment later.
At the same time, it’s currently very trendy to “coach” and “therapize” people–that’s a personal decision. For both sides. I prefer to mediate between humans and dogs. In my opinion, there are specialists for psychotherapy.
Also interesting: My biggest mishaps as a dog trainer
Speak Up Before You Leave
Nina Ponath calls it assertive communication: setting boundaries clearly and kindly. I would add: Don’t wait until you’re leaving to do this. If something doesn’t suit you, say it during the session. For example: This doesn’t fit into my daily life, how can we solve this differently? A good trainer appreciates this feedback because they can only adjust what they know.
If someone reacts to friendly, clear feedback with offense, condescension, or inflexibility, you have your answer. Then you can leave with a clear conscience and without justification. But if they respond with interest, explain their reasons, and offer alternatives, you’ve likely found someone you can work with. At the same time, it’s worth mentioning: A group session is not private instruction.
“I Won’t Put Up With Everything in Dog Training School Anymore”
5 Things You Shouldn’t Subject Your Dog To
And the Dog? They’re in the Same Boat
In all the discussion about owners and trainers, we sometimes forget the third party, who is asked the least. Your dog experiences every session directly. They show you if it fits, often more clearly than any explanation. Do they go to the session happily, work attentively, and come out relaxed? Or do they pull back on the way to the place, pant, yawn, sniff frantically, or are completely exhausted afterward? Then it’s worth taking a closer look. A good trainer also sees these signals and adjusts the training.
The Compatibility Checklist
For You as the Owner:
☐ I feel taken seriously and can ask questions.
☐ Methods are explained to me and not imposed.
☐ My dog and my daily life are considered.
☐ My dog appears relaxed in training and enjoys working.
☐ There is no violence, intimidation, or blanket judgments.
☐ The trainer can admit when they don’t know something.
For the One-on-One Conversation:
☐ Have I clearly stated my goals and boundaries?
☐ Have I honestly said how my dog behaves?
☐ Am I willing to practice between sessions?
☐ Have I addressed criticism calmly and specifically?
My Conclusion
Good dog training is not a service where one delivers and the other consumes. It’s a collaboration between people, dog, and trainer. That you don’t have to put up with anything is right and important. That a trainer also has boundaries is equally so. Those who respect both are more likely to find someone who truly fits. And as Nina Ponath describes for her own trainer, it’s ultimately about someone who looks at the dog and how they feel, and that you understand each other as a team and not as a problem case.