Skip to content
logo The magazine for all pet owners and lovers
cat behaviour All topics
Feelings of Guilt?

Many cat owners completely misinterpret this look from their feline.

A young cat ripped open a bag of flour, creating a big mess on the floor. His owner caught him in the act and now stands over him. The kitten appears remorseful and ashamed as he sheepishly looks up at his human friend.
Can Cats Actually Feel Guilty? Photo: Getty Images

November 16, 2026, 12:50 pm | Read time: 3 minutes

The chaos is set, the cat sits in the middle and looks up at its human with big eyes. For many owners, it’s immediately clear: She knows exactly what she did. But the seemingly guilty look actually means something entirely different.

Do Cats Feel Guilt?

A direct sensation of guilt or shame cannot be proven in cats. Veterinarian Sandra C. Mitchell writes on the PetMD portal that cats do not feel guilt or remorse like humans. Guilt requires evaluating one’s actions. A cat that knocks items off a shelf acts according to its instinct, not because it wants to do something “bad.”1,2

Why Does My Cat Look Guilty Then?

When a cat hides or keeps its distance after a mishap, it’s usually due to fear of the consequences, such as the owner’s reaction. Flattened ears or a crouched posture can quickly appear to humans as an admission of guilt. However, they are often misinterpreted.

Also interesting: How well do you understand your cat? One in four fails

What Does the Research Say?

We haven’t found a study on cats and guilt. However, the “guilty look” in dogs is well-researched. Psychologist Alexandra Horowitz found in 2009 that dogs showed typical guilt signals more often when scolded, regardless of whether they had done something forbidden. Notably, innocent but scolded dogs showed more of these signals than those actually guilty. The Tufts Collaborative for Shelter Dogs summarizes that this look alone does not mean the dog knows of a wrongdoing. It is a reaction to being scolded.3,4

Whether this can be directly applied to cats is not proven. However, it aligns with what experts say about cats: Their body language likely shows insecurity or fear rather than remorse. Additionally, research by Moriah Galvan and Jennifer Vonk indicates that cats respond only slightly to human emotional signals, most notably when shown by their own owner.5

More on the topic

What About Purring and Head Bumping?

After a conflict, cats sometimes show reconciliation gestures like head bumping, purring, kneading, or slow blinking. According to PetMD, these are not apologies. They are meant to improve the mood.

What Should Owners Do?

Harsh punishment is ineffective. It can even increase the cat’s fear. Behaviors like scratching, urinating outside the litter box, bringing in live prey, or biting are normal for cats. To reduce them, PetMD suggests:

  • first checking with a veterinarian if a medical issue is causing the litter box problems
  • providing a scratching post
  • having one more litter box than the number of cats in the household
  • engaging the cat with interactive play

This article is a machine translation of the original German version of PETBOOK and has been reviewed for accuracy and quality by a native speaker. For feedback, please contact us at info@petbook.de.

Sources

You have successfully withdrawn your consent to the processing of personal data through tracking and advertising when using this website. You can now consent to data processing again or object to legitimate interests.